Ideas and messages
Arguments that challenge climate science, its seriousness or the need for policy action.
Institutions, resources and influence
Climate denial can be sustained by institutions, resources and networks. We will examine how they work together.
First distinction
The question is not simply why an individual doubts climate science. The unit of analysis is an organizational field.
Arguments that challenge climate science, its seriousness or the need for policy action.
Corporate actors, foundations, think tanks, front groups, experts, media and political allies can perform different functions.
Organized messages can enter public debate and political conflict across several arenas.
Why philanthropy matters here
Funding can create organizations, keep them active and give their arguments a public platform.
In the U.S. case studied here, foundations help establish and maintain think tanks and advocacy groups involved in opposing climate action.
Resources support staff, reports, communication and long-term participation in policy debates.
Intermediaries can make the original contributor less visible in public records.
Two readings, different questions
The readings examine the same broader field from complementary angles.
Riley E. Dunlap & Aaron M. McCright · 2011
Question: who acts, what roles do they play and how do claims move across institutions?
Robert J. Brulle · 2014
Question: which resources and organizations can be traced, and where do public records become incomplete?
Main reading: Dunlap and McCright, 2011
The main reading treats organized denial as an interconnected field, not the work of one actor.
Arguments about climate science, its seriousness or the need for policy action.
Corporate interests, foundations, think tanks, front groups, contrarian scientists, media and politicians can perform different roles.
Resources, credibility, amplification and political access help claims persist and circulate.
Opening vote
Six channels will appear. Choose the one you think matters most.
Map the network
Start with the material base.
Supply resources, coordination and policy pressure in the case examined by the authors.
Help sustain organizations and long-term ideological work.
Turn interests into reports, arguments and policy language.
Speak through organizations whose public identity can obscure sponsors.
Lend credentials and quotable expertise to counter-claims.
Amplify selected voices and frames.
Manufacture the appearance of spontaneous grassroots pressure.
Carry claims into hearings, campaigns and policy conflict.
Arenas of action: public discourse and policy conflict.
FRONTLINE / PBS · a case on film
Full video · 8:24
Your notes will anchor the next discussion.
A few keywords on paper or your device are enough.
Evidence first
The case involves fossil-fuel interests, public-relations professionals, scientific voices and journalists. Compare these with the actors in your notes.
Funding and communication work helped some voices gain exposure. A message can circulate through the press with the credibility of an apparently independent spokesperson.
One reference is the account of making third-party spokespersons available to reporters. It shows a communication relationship; by itself, it does not measure a policy effect. Other specific observations can also support the analysis.
Whole-group discussion
As a class, choose one actor and one connection. If each were removed, which loss would weaken the network more, and why?
From messages to resources
We have mapped how messages travel. Now we examine the resources that keep these organizations operating over time.
Robert J. Brulle (2014) · foundation funding and organizational capacity
Follow the resources
What is the climate change counter-movement?
A network of organizations opposing efforts to limit carbon emissions, including think tanks, advocacy groups and trade associations.
How is it financially maintained?
Organizations draw on multiple income sources. Brulle examines the foundation grants that public records allow him to identify.
How do funders and organizations interact as a network?
Grants link foundations to recipient organizations. The pattern reveals both the scale of support and how widely it reaches.
Documented foundation funding · 2003–2010
These figures cover documented foundation grants. They do not represent the movement's total income or each organization's climate-related spending.
Follow the money
Teaching diagram: $ means funding, not an amount. The final arrow represents communication and political activity, not a measured grant. Not all support passes through intermediaries.
Hypothetical example in equal units. These are not Brulle’s data.
Contributor A → $$ (2)
Contributor B → $$$ (3)
→ Organization X: $$$ (3)
→ Organization Y: $$ (2)
Amounts show the scale of support. Connections show which organizations a funder reaches. Neither alone proves a specific policy effect.
Evidence and its limits
A public grant record can identify a foundation, a recipient organization and an amount. This opens part of the financial relationship and its potential conflicts of interest to scrutiny.
When support passes through a donor-directed intermediary, the records examined by Brulle may reveal the intermediary without identifying the original contributor.
Round 2 · room tally
Think back to the network and funding discussion. The same six channels will appear.
Before / after
We asked the same question again to compare our initial hypotheses with the connections examined during the session. A change does not, by itself, prove learning.
What changed? What stayed the same? Which idea, actor or connection helps explain your view now?
Plenary debate
Ideas supply arguments, interests motivate opposition, and institutions give those arguments continuity and reach. The analysis explains how these elements interact.
Foundation support can help maintain the organizations that produce and circulate arguments over time.
Yes. An intermediary can make a grant visible while the original contributor remains unidentified. This does not establish their identity or how much control they exercise.
Disclosure can help the public examine financial ties and conflicts of interest. Another concern is protecting legitimate privacy and freedom of association. What information, thresholds and safeguards would be justified?
No. The label alone does not establish public benefit. Examine its purposes, supported activities, affected groups and accountability.
Conclusion
Identify the actors, their roles and the connections that give their messages reach.
Examine who funds these organizations, how support is distributed and where the public record stops.
Not every actor does the same thing. The central point is that institutions, resources, networks and public communication can sustain organized denial.
Climate and power
Created and presented by Eduardo Abel and Zander Martins.