CLIMATE & POWERClimate Change Denial

Institutions, resources and influence

Climate Change Denial

Climate denial can be sustained by institutions, resources and networks. We will examine how they work together.

01Define the problem
02Map the denial machine
03Follow the money
04Debate democratic implications

First distinction

What is organized climate change denial?

The question is not simply why an individual doubts climate science. The unit of analysis is an organizational field.

Claims

Ideas and messages

Arguments that challenge climate science, its seriousness or the need for policy action.

Organization

Actors and institutions

Corporate actors, foundations, think tanks, front groups, experts, media and political allies can perform different functions.

Consequences

Discourse and policy

Organized messages can enter public debate and political conflict across several arenas.

Individual skepticism does not imply participation in a coordinated campaign. Our focus is how institutions organize, fund and amplify climate denial.

Why philanthropy matters here

Private resources can become public influence

Funding can create organizations, keep them active and give their arguments a public platform.

Capacity

Funding builds organizations

In the U.S. case studied here, foundations help establish and maintain think tanks and advocacy groups involved in opposing climate action.

Continuity

Organizations sustain ideas

Resources support staff, reports, communication and long-term participation in policy debates.

Visibility

Donors may remain obscured

Intermediaries can make the original contributor less visible in public records.

This case shows how philanthropy can support organized denial. It does not mean that all philanthropy, foundations or think tanks serve that purpose.

Two readings, different questions

What does each author help us see?

The readings examine the same broader field from complementary angles.

Supporting reading

Robert J. Brulle · 2014

Follow the money

Question: which resources and organizations can be traced, and where do public records become incomplete?

First, we use Dunlap and McCright to define the machine. Then Brulle helps investigate the resources that sustain part of it.

Main reading: Dunlap and McCright, 2011

What is the denial machine?

The main reading treats organized denial as an interconnected field, not the work of one actor.

Ideas

Claims

Arguments about climate science, its seriousness or the need for policy action.

Actors

Different roles

Corporate interests, foundations, think tanks, front groups, contrarian scientists, media and politicians can perform different roles.

Connections

What makes the machine work

Resources, credibility, amplification and political access help claims persist and circulate.

The supporting reading, Brulle, adds a question: what resources sustain part of this field, and what do public records make visible or leave hidden?

Opening vote

Which channel is most likely to sustain organized influence over the climate-policy debate?

Start with your own hypothesis

Six channels will appear. Choose the one you think matters most.

Map the network

Build the Denial Machine

Start with the material base.

FRONTLINE / PBS · a case on film

Watch and note the connections

Full video · 8:24

Your notes will anchor the next discussion.

Watch and take notes

  • One actor visible or mentioned
  • One connection to another actor
  • One detail you hear or see that supports that connection

A few keywords on paper or your device are enough.

Evidence first

What did we just see?

Which actors appear?

Compare with a reference

The case involves fossil-fuel interests, public-relations professionals, scientific voices and journalists. Compare these with the actors in your notes.

What connected them?

Compare with a reference

Funding and communication work helped some voices gain exposure. A message can circulate through the press with the credibility of an apparently independent spokesperson.

Which detail supports your interpretation?

Compare with a reference

One reference is the account of making third-party spokespersons available to reporters. It shows a communication relationship; by itself, it does not measure a policy effect. Other specific observations can also support the analysis.

Whole-group discussion

Find the network's weak point

As a class, choose one actor and one connection. If each were removed, which loss would weaken the network more, and why?

05:00

From messages to resources

From the actors to their funding

We have mapped how messages travel. Now we examine the resources that keep these organizations operating over time.

Robert J. Brulle (2014) · foundation funding and organizational capacity

Follow the resources

Three questions shift the analysis

01

What is the climate change counter-movement?

Reveal explanation

A network of organizations opposing efforts to limit carbon emissions, including think tanks, advocacy groups and trade associations.

02

How is it financially maintained?

Reveal explanation

Organizations draw on multiple income sources. Brulle examines the foundation grants that public records allow him to identify.

03

How do funders and organizations interact as a network?

Reveal explanation

Grants link foundations to recipient organizations. The pattern reveals both the scale of support and how widely it reaches.

Documented foundation funding · 2003–2010

A network becomes measurable

140foundations
5,299grants
US$558Mdocumented grants
91recipient organizations

These figures cover documented foundation grants. They do not represent the movement's total income or each organization's climate-related spending.

Follow the money

Money connects organizations

→

Foundations & donor-directed intermediaries

partly visible
→

Think tanks & advocacy organizations

visible recipients
→activity

Public & policy arenas

outcomes to discuss

Teaching diagram: $ means funding, not an amount. The final arrow represents communication and political activity, not a measured grant. Not all support passes through intermediaries.

How contributions can pool and spread

Hypothetical example in equal units. These are not Brulle’s data.

Contributor A → $$ (2)

Contributor B → $$$ (3)

Intermediary: $$$$$ (5)

→ Organization X: $$$ (3)

→ Organization Y: $$ (2)

What do amounts show, and what do connections add?

Amounts show the scale of support. Connections show which organizations a funder reaches. Neither alone proves a specific policy effect.

Evidence and its limits

Visible grants, hidden origins

What we can trace

A public grant record can identify a foundation, a recipient organization and an amount. This opens part of the financial relationship and its potential conflicts of interest to scrutiny.

Where the trail stops

When support passes through a donor-directed intermediary, the records examined by Brulle may reveal the intermediary without identifying the original contributor.

This gap limits scrutiny of the original sources of support. A hidden identity does not, by itself, prove a donor’s motive or control over the organization.

Round 2 · room tally

Which channel is most likely to sustain organized influence over the climate-policy debate?

Answer again before looking at the tally

Think back to the network and funding discussion. The same six channels will appear.

Before / after

Discussion

We asked the same question again to compare our initial hypotheses with the connections examined during the session. A change does not, by itself, prove learning.

What changed? What stayed the same? Which idea, actor or connection helps explain your view now?

Plenary debate

What should democracy require?

If private money sustains organizations in climate politics, what should the public be able to see?

Conclusion

One infrastructure, two analytical moves

Move 01

Look at the machine

Identify the actors, their roles and the connections that give their messages reach.

Move 02

Follow the money

Examine who funds these organizations, how support is distributed and where the public record stops.

Climate denial is not only an argument. It can also be an infrastructure.

Not every actor does the same thing. The central point is that institutions, resources, networks and public communication can sustain organized denial.

Climate and power

Thank you.

Created and presented by Eduardo Abel and Zander Martins.